Prince Harry

Prince Harry argues he received ‘inferior treatment’ after ‘feeling forced to step back as full-time working royal’ in High Court showdown


Prince Harry feels he has been ‘singled out’ for ‘unjustified, inferior treatment’ since Megxit, the Court of Appeal in London heard today.

The Duke of Sussex and his wife Meghan Markle ‘felt forced to step back’ from frontline royal duties in 2020 ‘as they considered they were not being protected by the institution’, his KC Shaheed Fatima has said.

Harry has flown 5,000 miles to be at the Royal Courts of Justice to support his own two-day appeal against a ruling over the right he, Meghan, Archie and Lilibet have to taxpayer-funded bodyguards while visiting the UK.

But hitting back the Home Office’s barrister said the Duke of Sussex’s appeal ‘involves a continued failure to see the wood for the trees’. 

It came as MailOnline revealed that Harry is not thought to have seen his father King Charles before the monarch jetted off for Italy for his four-day state visit this week.

The California-based royal is challenging the dismissal of his High Court legal action against the Home Office over the decision of the Executive Committee for the Protection of Royalty and Public Figures (Ravec) that he should receive a different degree of protection when in the country of his birth because he stepped down as a full-time royal.

His case has cost the British taxpayer £500,000 so far. 

Opening the Duke of Sussex’s appeal this morning, with her royal client sat just behind her, Ms Fatima said he had been ‘singled out’ for ‘inferior treatment’ when he was stripped of the high level of protection he was previously given by the Metropolitan Police.

‘When Ravec made its February 2020 decision about the appellant’s protective security, it did not apply its own terms of reference to that decision-making process’, she said, adding that Ravec came up with a ‘different and so-called ‘bespoke process’.

‘The appellant [Prince Harry] does not accept that ‘bespoke’ means ‘better’. In fact, in his submission, it means that he has been singled out for different, unjustified and inferior treatment’.

Prince Harry was sat in court following his lead counsel’s case, sipping from a plastic bottle of still mineral water as she spoke.

In written submissions submitted to the Court of Appeal today, Harry’s KC, viewed as a legal trailblazer because in 2016 she became Britain’s first hijab-wearing barrister, said: ‘This appeal concerns the most fundamental right: to safety and security of person’.

She continued: ‘On January 8 2020, (the Duke of Sussex) and his wife felt forced to step back from the role of full-time official working members of the royal family as they considered they were not being protected by the institution, but they wished to continue their duties in support of the late Queen as privately funded members of the royal family’.

A sombre Prince Harry has arrived at the High Court in London today

A sombre Prince Harry has arrived at the High Court in London today 

The Duke of Sussex is at the Royal Courts of Justice for the start of his appeal against a High Court ruling on his legal claim against the Home Office

The Duke of Sussex is at the Royal Courts of Justice for the start of his appeal against a High Court ruling on his legal claim against the Home Office

The Duke of Sussex's appeal against the dismissal of his legal challenge over the level of protection he and his family (pictured together at Christmas) is given while visiting the UK has begun at the Court of Appeal

The Duke of Sussex’s appeal against the dismissal of his legal challenge over the level of protection he and his family (pictured together at Christmas) is given while visiting the UK has begun at the Court of Appeal

The Duke of Sussex and his wife Meghan Markle 'felt forced to step back' from frontline royal duties in 2020 'as they considered they were not being protected by the institution', his KC Shaheed Fatima (pictured today) has said

The Duke of Sussex and his wife Meghan Markle ‘felt forced to step back’ from frontline royal duties in 2020 ‘as they considered they were not being protected by the institution’, his KC Shaheed Fatima (pictured today) has said

Ms Fatima later said that Harry was ‘not in a position to make any informed representations to Ravec’.

He added: ‘(His) security does not appear to have been discussed at any formal Ravec meeting and there are no official notes or detailed minutes recording the approach to be taken to (his) security and the rationale for it.’

According to Ms Fatima KC, when Ravec stripped the prince of his top-level security in February 2020, shortly after he and wife Meghan had announced they were stepping back from royal duties and relocating to North America, it did not follow his own rules.

And the judge who previously ruled Ravec had acted correctly, was mistaken.

Ms Fatima said according to its own guidelines, Ravec should have commissioned an assessment of Prince Harry’s particular security needs from another specialist body, the Risk Management Board. It has failed to do so, instead reaching its decision by ‘bespoke’ means.

Ms Fatima said: ‘The appellant [the Duke of Sussex] does not accept that bespoke means better – in fact, in his position, it means he has been singled out for different, inferior treatment.’

The hearing before Sir Geoffrey Vos, Lord Justice Bean, and Lord Justice Edis is due to conclude on Wednesday with a decision expected in writing at a later date. 

It came as MailOnline reveal that the King is not thought to have met with his youngest son when he flew into London from California at the weekend ahead of his High Court showdown today.

The Duke of Sussex landed from Los Angeles on Sunday but his father spent the weekend at Highgrove, his private Gloucestershire home, resting ahead of this week’s busy State Visit to Italy.

His Majesty then flew directly to Rome from RAF Brize Norton with Queen Camilla on Monday afternoon. It came after the Mail’s Richard Eden revealed Harry’s skipped the wedding of one of his so-called ‘band of brothers’ – despite being invited and in the UK.

Today, just as Harry walked purposefully into the Royal Courts of Justice for the 10am hearing, Charles and Camilla were afforded a ceremonial welcome including a flypast by Italian President Sergio Mattarella and his daughter, Laura Mattarella, at the Quirinale Palace on Tuesday.

The Duke of Sussex has decided to travel 5,000 miles to be at the High Court in London to support his own appeal against a ruling on the level of security he, Meghan Markle, Archie and Lilibet are afforded while in the country of his birth.

Wearing a suit, white shirt and tie, Harry arrived looking stern, clutching his mobile phone tightly. There was a brief smile and wave as he entered the historic building.

Harry’s long-term personal bodyguard Dave Langdown, 57, a former Metropolitan Police officer, entered the courtroom 20 minutes before the case was due to start. He scanned the room to ensure it was safe for the Prince’s evidently imminent arrival.

Harry waved to the crowds outside amid the ongoing rows with the UK Government and also his family

Harry waved to the crowds outside amid the ongoing rows with the UK Government and also his family

But MailOnline can reveal he did not see his father, pictured today in Rome with Queen Camilla, when they were briefly in the US at the same time on Sunday and Monday

But MailOnline can reveal he did not see his father, pictured today in Rome with Queen Camilla, when they were briefly in the US at the same time on Sunday and Monday

At 10.24am Prince Harry himself walked into court, clad in a charcoal grey suit. Offering a forced smile grimace to the media, he took a seat in the third row back from the judge, two rows behind his two King’s Counsel barristers, Shaheed Fatima and Jason Pobjoy.

Mr Langdown took a seat in the public gallery behind his boss.

Harry believes he is entitled to armed bodyguards, paid for by the British taxpayer, and is fighting a 2020 decision to reduce the level of security after he and Meghan Markle stepped back from life as working royals and emigrated to the United States.

He has expressed safety concerns about returning to the UK with his wife and children.

It came after landed in the UK just before King Charles III jetted off to Italy for a historic four-day state visit.

The King and his son are also believed to have differing views over Harry’s decision to pursue his legal fight with the Home Office, which has cost the British taxpayer £500,000 so far. 

Harry has been taking legal action in the UK over a decision made by the Executive Committee for the Protection of Royalty and Public Figures (Ravec) in February 2020 over the level of protection he should receive when in the country. 

The High Court previously heard that his ‘status’ had changed as a result of no longer being a ‘full-time working member of the Royal Family‘.

But Harry has argued his children, Prince Archie and Princess Lilibet cannot ‘feel at home’ or ‘safe’ in the UK unless his police protection is fully restored. 

His legal fight comes as the Charity Commission announced it had launched an investigation into Sentebale, the charity he founded, amid a bitter boardroom rift between Harry and chairwoman Dr Sophie Chandauka.

She has accused Prince Harry of ‘harassment and bullying’ – a claim that is denied.

Prince Harry flew into the UK just hours before King Charles jetted off to Italy for a historic four-day state visit

There was a brief smile for the cameras when Harry arrived. There were shouts asking whether he had seen his father

There was a brief smile for the cameras when Harry arrived. There were shouts asking whether he had seen his father

There was a brief smile for the cameras when Harry arrived. There were shouts asking whether he had seen his father

King Charles III and Queen Camilla are received by the President of the Italian Republic, His Excellency Signor Sergio Mattarella and the President's daughter, Signora Laura Mattarella at the Quirinale Palace

King Charles III and Queen Camilla are received by the President of the Italian Republic, His Excellency Signor Sergio Mattarella and the President’s daughter, Signora Laura Mattarella at the Quirinale Palace 

King Charles III, Queen Camilla, President of the Italian Republic, His Excellency Signor Sergio Mattarella and the President's daughter, Signora Laura Mattarella view a flypast by the Frecce Tricolori and Red Arrows at the Quirinale Palace

King Charles III, Queen Camilla, President of the Italian Republic, His Excellency Signor Sergio Mattarella and the President’s daughter, Signora Laura Mattarella view a flypast by the Frecce Tricolori and Red Arrows at the Quirinale Palace

King Charles and Queen Camilla are in the Italian capital, Rome, pictured at at Villa Wolkonsky

King Charles and Queen Camilla are in the Italian capital, Rome, pictured at at Villa Wolkonsky

For his part Harry, who stood down as patron of the charity last week alongside co-founder Prince Seeiso in support of a group of trustees who have also quit, has accused Ms Chanduaka of telling ‘blatant lies’.

He said they ‘fully expected [the investigation] will unveil the truth that collectively forced us to resign’. 

Prince Harry added: ‘We remain hopeful this will allow for the charity to be put in the right hands immediately, for the sake of the communities we serve.’

His arrival in the UK capital comes as the King and Queen jetted into Rome, before visiting the city of Ravenna, as they use the ‘soft power’ diplomacy of the monarchy to strengthen Britain’s relationship with its ally.

A separate state visit to the Holy See, the government of the Roman Catholic Church, in the Vatican, has been cancelled, as Pope Francis is recuperating after leaving hospital following treatment for double pneumonia.

With a number of Vatican events removed from the itinerary in Rome, the remaining engagements in the Italian capital have been spread over two days, and extra elements added to some engagements.

At the weekend the Pope made a surprise appearance in St Peter’s Square, in the Vatican. 

He appeared with an oxygen tube under his nose and was using a wheelchair.

King Charles waves from a car as he and Queen Camilla depart the Rome Ciampino Airport at the beginning of their four-day state visit to Italy

King Charles waves from a car as he and Queen Camilla depart the Rome Ciampino Airport at the beginning of their four-day state visit to Italy

The King and Queen pictured departing their flight ahead of their historic state visit to Italy

The King and Queen pictured departing their flight ahead of their historic state visit to Italy

Ciao fella: It is not known if King Charles III and Prince Harry met between their flights

Ciao fella: It is not known if King Charles III and Prince Harry met between their flights

The Duke of Sussex is back in London for an appeal against a High Court ruling on whether he is entitled to armed bodyguards paid for by the taxpayer

The Duke of Sussex is back in London for an appeal against a High Court ruling on whether he is entitled to armed bodyguards paid for by the taxpayer

The prince's legal fight comes as the Charity Commission announced it had launched an investigation into Sentebale, the charity he founded, amid a bitter boardroom rift between Harry and chairwoman Dr Sophie Chandauka (pictured)

The prince’s legal fight comes as the Charity Commission announced it had launched an investigation into Sentebale, the charity he founded, amid a bitter boardroom rift between Harry and chairwoman Dr Sophie Chandauka (pictured)

Dr Sophie Chandauka, pictured with Meghan and Harry at a polo event last year that sparked a row. A year on the trio have fallen out and the Duke of Sussex resigned from Sentebale

Dr Sophie Chandauka, pictured with Meghan and Harry at a polo event last year that sparked a row. A year on the trio have fallen out and the Duke of Sussex resigned from Sentebale

King Charles III and Queen Camilla at Clarence House in London on March 25

King Charles III and Queen Camilla at Clarence House in London on March 25

Charles will hold audiences with President Sergio Mattarella and Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni

Charles will hold audiences with President Sergio Mattarella and Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni 

Charles will become the first British monarch to address both houses of Italy’s parliament – the chamber of deputies and the senate of the republic.

The King will also hold audiences with President Sergio Mattarella and Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, and he and his wife will attend a black-tie state banquet at the Palazzo Quirinale, hosted by the president on the evening of their 20th wedding anniversary.

The UK and Italy’s defence co-operation will be marked by a joint flypast over Rome by the Italian air force’s aerobatic team, Frecce Tricolori, and the RAF’s Red Arrows.

In Ravenna, near Bologna, Charles and Camilla will mark the 80th anniversary of the province’s liberation from Nazi occupation by allied forces, on April 10 1945, during a town hall reception.

Charles and Camilla will attend a black-tie state banquet at the Palazzo Quirinale (pictured)

Charles and Camilla will attend a black-tie state banquet at the Palazzo Quirinale (pictured)

Pope Francis speaks to the faithful in St Peter's Square at the Vatican yesterday

Pope Francis speaks to the faithful in St Peter’s Square at the Vatican yesterday

They will celebrate literary culture by visiting Dante’s tomb and the Queen will make a solo trip to the Byron museum.

Charles returned to official public duties after cancelling a string of engagements last month, when he experienced temporary side effects from cancer treatment on March 27.

Buckingham Palace announced that the King had ‘required a short period of observation in hospital’ earlier that day.

Planned engagements in Birmingham the following day, March 28, were cancelled to prioritise his recovery as a precautionary measure.

A source described it as a ‘most minor bump in a road that is very much heading in the right direction’.



Source link

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button